It's Not Us vs. Them: Splits, Contractors, and Knowing Your Worth as a Group Practice Owner
Empowered to LeadNovember 10, 2026x
42
25:3417.55 MB

It's Not Us vs. Them: Splits, Contractors, and Knowing Your Worth as a Group Practice Owner

After jumping into some charged Facebook conversations, Lisa shares a bit of a rant about the growing us-versus-them divide between group practice owners and contractors. She talks about how owners sometimes fuel it themselves, why an independent contractor relationship is business to business, and how knowing your numbers and letting both sides' realities be true helps you lead with confidence instead of resentment.

What You’ll Hear:

  • How group practice owners can feed the us-versus-them mentality themselves, especially when they're burnt out or haven't decided who they want to be as a leader
  • Why choosing a 70/30 or 80/20 split because "that's what everyone else is doing" can leave you unable to provide what your team needs
  • Knowing your value: the environment, culture, clients, and leadership you provide all have worth, and a dollar value
  • Why an independent contractor relationship is business to business, not business to employee, and how that changes what you can ask contractors to do to help fill their caseload
  • The mindset shift: you're paying contractors for a service their business provides yours, not giving to them or taking from them
  • Defining what profit means for you, whether that's income, time off, flexibility, or the capacity to pour into your people
  • Considering what it's like to be a contractor right now, and how to understand their perspective without letting go of your own
  • Five questions to ask yourself before your next conversation about your split

Resources Mentioned on this Episode

- This week's companion blog post, with the reflection questions Lisa walks through: https://www.grouppracticenetwork.ca/blog//contractor-split-group-practice-both-sides

- The Numbers Room, returning in the new year to help you figure out what it actually costs to run your practice: https://numbers-room.grouppracticenetwork.ca/numbers-room/

- GPO Network, Lisa's free Facebook group for group practice owners: https://www.facebook.com/groups/gponetwork

- Group Practice Connection, Lisa's membership for Canadian group practice owners, with peer support, quick responses from Lisa, and resources and templates: https://www.grouppracticenetwork.ca/the-group-practice-connection

- Have thoughts on the us-versus-them conversation? Lisa would love your feedback. Send her a message to lisa@grouppracticenetwork.ca

Reflection Prompts for the Week

  • Do I know what it costs my practice to deliver one session, including a fair wage for my own time?
  • How transparent am I willing to be, and am I confident enough in my split to stick with it?
  • Have I been realistic and clear about how I'll help fill a caseload, and what I expect from my contractors?
  • Do any of my rules look more like employment than an independent contractor relationship?
  • Am I letting both sides' realities be true, or am I only wanting mine to be true?

Meet the Host: Lisa Catallo

Lisa is a Canadian psychotherapist, group practice owner, and business coach with over eight years of experience leading a thriving, values-driven practice. She works with therapists who are ready to step into their role as confident, ethical, and intentional leaders—without burning out or getting buried in the day-to-day.

Lisa’s coaching focuses on building sustainable group practices through efficient systems, effective leadership, and a deep respect for time and energy. Her approach is calm and encouraging, offering grounded guidance that helps therapists move from overwhelm to clarity—so they can lead with confidence and purpose.

Whether she’s supporting someone just starting to grow a team or helping a seasoned leader reclaim their role as CEO, Lisa brings a blend of insight, structure, and heart to everything she does.

When she’s not coaching or connecting with therapists, you’ll find her hanging out with her children and grandchildren, reading, walking by the water, or dreaming up new ways to make business feel a little lighter.

Connect with the Host:

Website: www.grouppracticenetwork.ca

Instagram: instagram.com/grouppracticenetwork

Facebook: facebook.com/grouppracticenetwork

LinkedIn:www.linkedin.com/in/lisa-catallo

Loved this episode? Let’s take it a step further.

Grab the free Time + Energy Audit for Group Practice Owners to get super clear on where your time is going—and what it’s actually worth.

👉 Download it here

And if you're ready for consistent support, connection, and access to done-for-you tools? Come join us inside Group Practice Connection—the membership designed to help Canadian group practice owners lead with clarity and confidence.

✨ You don’t have to do this alone. Check it out here

Empowered to Lead is proud to be on the High Vibe Podcast Network Check out Lisa's Gift in the Vault https://highvibepodcastnetwork.com/gifts

Share the Love

✨ If this episode lit something up in you… tag us on Instagram @HighVibeLeaders and @grouppracticenetwork and let us know your biggest takeaway!

🦋 Don’t forget to rate & review — it helps us reach more conscious rebels like you.

Listen & Subscribe

🎧 Apple Podcasts

🎧 Spotify

🎧 Amazon Music

🎧 High Vibe Podcast Network

Lisa Catallo:

Welcome back to the Empowered to Lead podcast. This is a space for clinic owners, group practice owners, people who are therapists who have brought on a team around them to support the community around them. And the purpose of this podcast is to help you know that you are not alone as a group practice owner. We have taken on a responsibility, and in the title of the podcast is "Empowered to Lead." You'll hear me quite often over the last year and a half saying that I think we need to step up as leaders, and I think that that is a big part of building a sustainable and thriving business. And in that is also: Are you making sure that this business works for you? Are you creating really good systems? Do you know who you want to be have on your team? Do you know who you want to be as a leader, and so throughout the podcast episodes, we have tackled a bunch of these different topics. I love having the conversations that I get to have with a variety of group practice owners and other professionals as I try to find ways to support you as group practice owners. I also feel strongly about certain things when it comes to leadership, and primarily as a mental health therapist who owns a group practice. There are things that I think are crucial for having a really good business and something that works for you rather than you working for it. One of those things is definitely systems. Have your systems and your structure have operating procedures. Those are crucial. I think you want to know who your ideal client is for your group practice, and then identify who your ideal therapist is for you as a leader. There's other things like knowing your numbers. I think is crucial. One of the biggest things that I have heard, especially growing over the last year or two, probably the last two years, is a sense of us versus them, at least in the mental health world, and it feels like this is happening more and more in the conversations, at least that

Lisa Catallo:

I see happening in Facebook, in the Facebook world, however you might call that, and so today is a little bit different. Typically, in my podcast schedule, I'll have a guest come on, and then I'll spend a couple of other episodes giving a little bit of my perspective and some steps, and then the next one would be some really practical tools. Today, I want to rant a little bit, and I hope that you'll bear with me. And also, give me your feedback. I'd love to hear your perspective on this topic. So, if you get my newsletter or if you read a blog, you know that last weekend I engaged in a couple of conversations on Facebook. I was feeling a little spicy. My teenager would friendship me using that word, but when I engage in these Facebook groups with some of these charged topics, the main reason why I want to engage is, first of all, that you as a group practice owner know that you aren't alone. To know that there's somebody out there seeing that these conversations are happening, and to support you, that would be one of the main reasons why I ever do answer in any of those groups. The other one is to try and help people have a different perspective, or to understand what happens as a group practice owner, and also to help us as group practice owners have a bit of a perspective on what's going on for our contractors. So, if we are part of a collective, if we are identified with other group practice owners who are not treating their people well, who don't have realistic or honest or like really good expectations of their team, if they take advantage of them, if just give us put us in a negative light that doesn't help us at all. So, what is my rant about? That us versus them mentality. And a lot of us, as group practice owners, can say, "Yeah, you know, contractors they think that we're just taking from them, and they have a really negative view on.". Us and that's really hard to watch, and that is true.

Lisa Catallo:

But also, some of us perpetuate that us versus them mentality, and I think that starts to happen when we are feeling burnt out as a group practice owner, that we haven't identified who we are as a leader, how we want to show up. What a business actually should could look like in order to be thriving and sustainable. And so it's a little bit of what I'm thinking right now. When you start your group practice and you are bringing on associates, a lot of us started out of what is everybody else providing for a split? What like you know? Okay, well it sounds like don't even necessarily do all the homework. It sounds like everyone around me is doing a 7030 split. I've heard as high as 8020 split, and so that must be what I have to do, and also like, why would anybody want to join a group practice if they weren't going to make as much money as possible? So in order to get people to join me, I have to give really good split. They have to be paid well, and yes, I think that clinicians should be paid well to do the work that they're doing, and do your math. Know your numbers. Know what you your unique business needs in order to survive, in order to keep bringing in clients, in order to pay for you for all the effort that you are putting into making this group practice work, in order to cover the admin so that you're not seeing another five clients a week, so that you can pay for an admin to support everyone in your group. Know your numbers. Slow down. Be realistic, and in that, when I'm talking about know your numbers, know your value, people come and join a group practice because they either don't have a business mindset, or they don't want to do the admin. They want to come in and see clients and go. And yes, there are people who come to a group practice because they want to learn some of those skills, or they want to build up their caseload, and then leave. And those ones are hard. You get to choose whether you want that kind of therapist on your team, but know

Lisa Catallo:

your value. You are providing an environment, a culture, the kind of clients that you want to serve, you have value just in how you show up as a leader, and that has $1 to it. That has worth. People are willing to pay for good services. You know, you you hear that old adage: you get what you pay for, so if you're giving everybody 7030 or 8020 without knowing your numbers, they're getting 20% worth of what you're able to provide or what you can provide. Imagine if you did a 6040 split and you're being compensated properly. How different you're going to show up, what kinds of things you can actually provide for the business versus 8020. And hear me, I'm not saying everybody has to be 6040. I'm saying know your numbers. I'm just throwing those splits out as that's what I hear quite often. Know your numbers and answer the question of why would somebody want to join a group practice. Be curious. Go into some of those groups. What when I looked in those groups, there's also somebody said, "Hey, I'm hiring," and there were so many people that replied, "I'm going to reach out. I'm looking for something." There are people out there that want you to lead them. They want to have the support and what you are offering. So that's enough on that one. The other part that I want to talk about is know what it means to have a contractor and what it means to be a contractor. So when you decide on that split, you are just like, "Oh, I'm doing this out of the goodness of my heart." Some of you are doing that. Some of you are saying, "I need to compensate you really well, and I have to do everything for you in order for you to want to join me. I was just actually interviewing somebody to come on the podcast and do a workshop for us about from an HR perspective, and she used this line that.

Lisa Catallo:

I think a lot of us forget that when you have an independent contractor, it's a business-to-business relationship rather than a business-to-employee relationship. And us as group practice owners think of them as employees rather than an independent contractor who is running their own business, so that means you can ask them to participate in getting clients. You can ask them to write blogs. You can ask them to do a really good bio, or to you know require that they do really good work. And it's okay to ask them to help you get clients through the door, especially with the business that we have. It's based on relationship and how are clients going to know if it's a good if this person is a good fit if they're hiding and the only person that they meet or talk to is you or your admin? That doesn't actually help them get and retain clients. They're running a business, and as a contractor, they run the risk of reward and of lack of reward of losing money. So, the one of the ways that I would typically encourage you, or the way that I would describe it would be: if I have employees, I can be so directive. I can say, "This is what I know it takes to build a business. This is what you have to do within this timeline, because you are an employee of my business, and I can tell you what to do." With a contractor, you get to say, "Here's what I know it takes to build a caseload. Here's the options. Which ones are you willing to participate in?" And then let them participate as much as they're able to. Let them suffer the consequences of not participating. And you know, if you don't do these things, it's going to take longer to fill up your caseload. Or if you don't do these things, you won't fill up your caseload. Participate, care for your business. You are a business owner. Think like one. And I'm saying that to you as a group practice owner. I'm also saying that to the contractor. When one of the things that really gets me when people are like, "Oh, they're they're just

Lisa Catallo:

taking," or you know, they take the the 6040 split. No, you as a group practice owner are paying them for a service that their business is providing your business, and so you are compensating them, you are paying them. You're not giving them, you're not taking from them. Though we, as group practice owners, need to switch our thinking on that as well. So that actually went into. I'm just looking at my notes. Have the right mindset. I'm going to reiterate that you are paying for a service, you aren't just giving them money. This isn't a feel-good thing. We don't work for free. You have bills to pay. You have a family to take care of. You have. You need to be compensated, or you could just go work for a nonprofit and volunteer all your time if you didn't actually need to make money. So you and your contractor need to make money and needs to be a realistic number. And I want you to think this is your business. You are bringing on independent contractors to make your business work, it needs to work for you. What do you want? What do you need this business to provide you with? What do you want and need from the people that work for you in order to make that business work? And this is going to look different for everybody out there. Some of you are going to say, "I need to make a certain income because I'm the main breadwinner, or our house needs this much money." And so, in order to see my group practice as being successful or profitable, that translates into the salary that I take home. For others, it is that translates into me really being able to build a business and pour into people. We have enough money at home that you know being paid means I don't have to see as many clients, so that I can pour more into these people. I still think you should be compensated properly, but that might be part of it. For some of you, it's I don't want to see clients, or I want to be able to take time off.

Lisa Catallo:

And so, yes, maybe I take a lower salary, but the fact that I can take this time off or have. This flexibility, that is what profit looks like for me. So know that know what you want the business to provide for yourself. Be confident in what that means numbers wise, what that means structure wise, what that means with your culture, what you want and can provide as a leader, and what you want and need in order to provide that for your team and for the clients around you. But most of us don't just do this as a hobby. This is a very expensive hobby. It's also one of your biggest investments, and so it needs to have a healthy return on investment. What does that mean for you? And then put a number to that. How does that translate into what you can and want to pay your contractors? It's also to know. Keep in mind that there are people in your business. There are contractors who do need to make a living. So, for you know, I haven't heard of anybody doing this, but if you did a 4060 split, that wouldn't really be fair compensation for the therapist. Or if you are demanding that they provide everything or provide so many things. If you are so restrictive, that's not actually keeping into consideration who are they as a contractor. What's realistic to expect of them? How do I compensate them fairly and well for the work that they're doing? How do I encourage them? All of those things. Consider what it's like to be a contractor. Remember that they're running a business too. That's another thing that I would encourage you. A lot of times, when we get resentful or we're feeling like this isn't worth it, we start thinking of them as the bad guys, and they're taking from us. They are just coming in, filling a caseload, and then they're taking off, or all they want is to see is to get clients. They don't care about anything else in the culture. Well, yeah, they're running a business. They need to make money. They have their own business goals. They're not always in alignment

Lisa Catallo:

with you, and they are not going to fully understand you and the role that you have, because that's not a role that they have chosen. Whether that's yet or ever, this it's not. You're you're not comparing apples to apples. So, what does this mean? Oh no, there's a part where I just get. I don't want us to look at people as us and them. I want you. I want them to consider what are some of the needs that are happening on the other side. How can I try to understand as best as possible what the perspective is that they are bringing here? How can I help you feel heard and validate that, and then make a decision of whether I can or want to? Am I able to meet that need? Just because I don't fully understand your perspective, or just because we're not exactly on the same page doesn't mean that we can't get along. We can have some understanding of how hard it is to meet financial needs right now, how expensive the world is, how scary it is to join a group practice and quote unquote have 40% taken off of the fee that they see being charged to a client, I would argue in that that if you're doing your own business, you're losing a certain percentage in order to get the clients, in order to you know do the marketing, in order to have the lights on, all of that stuff, and they may not entirely understand that. Do you want to educate them? How much education do you want to give them? What helps you minimize resentment and having that us versus them mentality? Group practice is a beautiful place to be. Being a leader is such a huge responsibility, and that requires a good perspective and looking at the whole landscape, considering what people's needs are, what you're able to provide, and what you're not able to provide, and stepping out in confidence in those things, whether that's numbers, policies and procedures, structure, culture, all of those things. So here's some questions that I put on the blog that I want you to consider. Do I know what it costs my.

Lisa Catallo:

Practice my business to deliver one session, including a fair wage for my own time. Have you broken it down to say this is how many hours I spend leading this business? This is how much time I spend on admin. This would be $1 value for that. This is how much rent or technology costs me in order to run my practice. Do you know actually what it costs to run your practice? I'll do a little aside there. We're gonna do the numbers room again in the new year. That will help you figure that out. We're also gonna have other episodes talking about that. Another question is: How transparent am I willing to be, and am I confident enough in my split to stick with it? So if I know why I have chosen this split, what it covers, how much how much do I want to inform somebody, and am I doing that out of defense, or am I doing that as let's let's get as understanding as possible from as much as you are able in your shoes to understand my shoes. Another question is: Have I been realistic and clear about how I will help fill a caseload and what I expect from my contractors, so if they are running their own business, what do I expect from them, and what do I expect from myself in order to make my business run? Do any of my rules look more like employment than independent contractor? And if they do, how do I want to change those so that I am very clear. I either have employees or contractors. This is how I want to run my business. And the last question: Am I letting both sides' realities be true, or am I only wanting mine to be true? And what does that mean for a mindset shift, an understanding of how you want to proceed. I hope that you stuck with me to the end here. I hope you hear. I am not judging people. I am wanting us to figure out how to run our business as well, how to lead our people well, how to give the benefit of the doubt, validate people's needs and fears and concerns, while also validating ours and finding worth in that. Again, this was a little

Lisa Catallo:

bit of a rant, a little bit different podcast. I didn't. I had some points that I wanted to, so I went off on on other things, but I hope you hear me. I care about you. I care about who you are as a leader. I want you to build a business that works well for you. I want you to know your worth. I want you to have confidence in what you are paying the team around you, while understanding that some people may not want to join you because of that, and that doesn't mean anything negative about either of you. Walk in confidence. Know know these answers. Know what you're providing. What your business needs to provide for you, and let's grow something great. I would love to hear your feedback. How do you feel about this us versus them thing? Have you gotten sucked into it? Do you need any support in not being in that? My Facebook group is GPO Network. If you are not in there already, there's a ton of really great support happening in there. If you want a little bit more intimate group and support, there's group practice connection where we have peers. You get quick responses from me plus resources and templates, but mostly to know that you are not alone in this. There's also other offerings, but I want you to know you are not alone. That you are supported. That you are seen, and I want you to find value in you and what you're offering. Have a great day, and we will see you back here next week.